mustachian spotting uk – level 2
I’ve written before about Mustachian Spotting, a fun game where you attempt to spot people with the sort of characteristics that might lend them to the Financial Independence scene.
I’ve recently reached level 2 of this game recently, what excitement! Let me tell you what this entails:
This is where you get as far as having a real life conversation (I know!) with the potential fellow FI’er and to try to get a handle on whether they’ve heard of the most famous websites or books out there – I normally mention MMM and YMOYL 1 – to see if they are indeed already a confirmed worshipper at the alter of the Moustachioed one (or other FI pioneer).
It doesn’t matter whether they actually are or not, you will successfully defeat the end of level boss simply by having the balls to ask the question. I think this is a fair enough qualification for victory here, as stumping up the sentence:
“So have you heard of this website called Mr Money Mustache?”
Midway through an otherwise relatively normal conversation can seem rather odd if the person hasn’t already heard of it, and it is likely they haven’t, even if you think they are a secret MMM reader. I found a great tip for making this seem more normal is to ply them and yourself with alcohol first 🙂
I can unfortunately let you know that on the two occasions I made it to level 2 recently, the hit rate for having heard of any of this stuff was a big fat zero percent, so no extra special hidden fireworks ending after defeating this particular boss, but it was fun even getting to the point where I felt it was worth asking.
Here is a rough run down of my two level 2 encounters, as despite the zero hit rate there were some interesting things that cropped up in conversation.
Mr M – This is my cousin and her Husband Mr M who I wrote about in the earlier mentioned Mustachian Spotting UK post. They quit their London jobs and moved to a nice cottage in Kent a few years ago. I finally got to catch up with him at family wedding a month or so ago and started firing questions at him like a rabid MSUK player on his first level 2 outing would naturally do. I’m not sure if he thought I was odd or being too nosey about their finances and how the move played out, but I would imagine most people are curious about how they’ve effectively retired in their mid forties so I hoped he was used to it.
Anyway, as mentioned he had not heard of anything about MMM et al, and when pressed further on if he’d read any literature about this sort of thing at all that might have started him down this path, he couldn’t really think of any. He just said it seemed to make sense to save as much of his pay packet from the off. Truly badass to come to these conclusions on your own! I’m sure there are plenty of you out there reading this that have done the same but it was never anything my tiny brain could have come up with on it’s own… 🙂
We carried on generally chatting about life down in the Kent countryside and it turned out he has already gone back to work, as a librarian I think it was – slightly more chilled out than a job in the city though, right? Other fun/interesting insights that were mentioned:
- Everyone in the countryside drives everywhere – He gets funny looks for walking to the local village which is about 1 mile away. And he commutes to work by bike which again is very uncommon apparently!
- He said it was harder to live off investments than they initially imagined – I think he both meant literally, as in their expenses were higher than they initially thought, and mentally, as in they were not used to removing money from the cash pile rather than adding to it. Hence the job, and my cousin is also working part time now as well.
- They both said that living out in the sticks was quite hard in terms of seeing old friends, family and so on.
- Initially he’d planned on growing 50%+ of his food in their decent sized garden but for the amount of effort you have to put in he’s come to the conclusion that for most things it’s not really worth it (e.g. huge bag of potatoes can be bought for £2 whereas growing your own involves hours of hard work)
Mr A – This is my old work colleague who lives in France, and we went to visit him midway through our holiday we just got back from. He actually got made redundant a few years ago, and I wrote about that here:
“I was really quite surprised at how bewildered he seemed. This was a guy who I would say is pretty frugal. Without revealing too much, he had managed to set up a pretty cushy living situation for himself whereby he could work from home in a mortgage free house with his family. He could well have passed for a closet FI’er if I didn’t know any better. So I would have thought he would have some cashola saved up for a rainy day. He may well have for all I know, but I got the feeling from our conversation that it didn’t amount to anything that substantial if he had. Alternatively I could be way of the mark”
Well I am very happy to say that as it turned out I was waaaay off the mark! It turned out that he basically went straight into semi retirement and has been pottering about the house, fixing things up, and generally loving life for the past 2 and a bit years. I guess the whole bewilderment thing was literally just the shock of getting made redundant out of the blue, which is totally fair enough! Despite admitting that redundancy was probably the best thing that has happened to him, he was still bitter about the way it was handled, again totally fair play here as it was handled very badly and he put his life and soul into working for the company for a good 10 years. Anyway, back to the matter at hand… the finances!
So we got to chatting after a few vin rouges one night and I asked a few probing questions, and it turned out he has investments and said he was saving hard when working, and that’s when I asked about MMM and drew yet another blank. Bit of a shame but again it was good to hear there are other people out there making good financial decisions, living well within their means and putting the surplus to good use to create better life options for themselves. Some interesting facts about this particular situation and conversation:
- They sold their London flat and bought a house in France for a measly 160,000 Euros 2. This equated to about £120,000 at the time. This is a 6 bedroom, (yes 6!!!) lovely old farm type house, with a garden the size of a football pitch. That is geographical arbitrage my friends!
- His wife is still working but is enjoying doing so again after taking time off to raise the young kids into slightly less younger kids.
- He is also working part time but the jobs sounds pretty cushty, are very low schedule/hours, and spends most of the days just maintaining and fixing up the house.
- The main part of their plan going forward is to properly renovate half the house and split it off, and rent it out as a holiday home. He reckoned they could pull in about £30K a year from it (!!!) which I’d imagine is easily enough to cover most of their living expenses out there as there is not that much that is spendy to do in the remote French countryside.
- He had a bit of a moan about how hard it is to maintain the house. Just a reminder that no matter how idyllic someones life looks, there will always have problems just like you, they just might be different ones.
- He said he’d put some money into his kids investment fund accounts back in the Tony Blair/Labour days. I’d never heard of this but apparently it was free money, I can’t remember exactly what it was called but maybe other people can fill me in on that one? In any case it’s a break that is obviously not available now. He said he’d stuck it in some Biotech fund that has done very well for itself, he was very bullish on Biotech – I said I think I’d stick to a broad market tracker thank you very much for the advice though 🙂
The four important takeaways I got from these conversations:
- Financial security and indeed fully blown Financial Independence is not the silver bullet to all of your problems.
- Life is all about compromise, even if you’ve done all of the hard work and savings like a good boy or girl.
- Downsizing/geographical arbitrage is the perfect example of these two above points, you get “the good life” but swap this for remote friends and family and swap many of your old problems for some new and different ones.
- My theory that having a part time job or being self employed seems to be the optimal situation for happiness seems to be validated by all parties still holding down these kinds of jobs.
Hope you found reading about that as interesting as I found completing these level 2 quests!
Have you guys reached level 2 at all? Let me know in the comments!
Oh and one final thought… what should the completion of level 3 entail?! 🙂
Notes:
- Your Money or Your Life (amazon affiliates link) –
- No it’s not the castle pictured above, just in case you were wondering… 🙂 – That is just a random French castle we came across on our travels! It’s called the Chateau de Pierrefonds if anyone wanted to know. ↩
Amen to conclusion 4: that is my plan, hence I like it a lot!
Hehe, surely a bit of confirmation bias going on here but hey, we are all awesome right so must be correct? 😉
I should have mentioned in the article that I met your good self, the MadFIentist, and many other FI/mustachians at the Fincon Masters event the other week!
It wouldn’t count towards the MSUK game because obviously I knew in advance everyone was into this whole thing, but it was definitely worth mentioning for sure. Hopefully everyone reads down to the comments 🙂
I stumbled upon a potential Mustachian by suggesting a drink after work the day before payday. I hadn’t noticed before that we tended to go out on or just after payday; because I am a reasonable person and was under the impression that if you can’t afford £5 for one drink the day before payday you won’t be spending £50 on ten drinks the day after payday. Oh how wrong I was.
So the upside is that I found one relatively frugal colleague (we waxed lyrical about the wonders of index investing). The downside is that I outed myself as someone who has more than zero money before payday.
Hahaha, this is so true.
Actually people at my work don’t seem to be too bad but have plenty of adult friends in their 30’s now who still seem to have issues just before pay day.
Have you experienced any negativity from the other work colleagues for outing yourself as someone who is sensible with money then? (hope not!)
Not negativity as such, but I drew attention to myself in a way that I didn’t intend. Very gentle teasing, but it surprised me that it was note worthy at all. More like “well look who’s moneybags” than anything mean. I’ve also noticed since then colleagues are quicker to suggest that I buy birthday/leaving presents and slower to pay me back than they were before. No great harm done but I didn’t see it coming.
Especially as it only takes a credit card to be able to spend next month’s paycheque!
Hi FS,
I suppose he was talking about a CTF (Child Trust Fund). It was Gordon Brown who came up with it I think.
One of my daughters was entitled to the Government “free” contribution and one of them wasn’t, as it was only available for a short while. We them transferred it to a Junior ISA.
The following is from the Money Advice Service.
HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) sent the parents or guardians of qualifying children a starting payment voucher of £50 or £250, depending on when your child became entitled to an account. This voucher could then be used to set up a Child Trust Fund account in the child’s name.
Money in a Child Trust Fund account belongs to the child and is ‘locked in’ until they turn 18.
There are three types of account that can be opened with the voucher – ‘stakeholder’, share or savings account. Either way, your child doesn’t have to pay tax on the income or gains (profit) they make in their account. And, the money your child gets won’t affect any benefits or tax credits you receive.
Family member payments to a Child Trust Fund
Parents, family members and friends can between them pay in up to £4,128 each year, with the child’s birthday considered the start of the year.
Cheers
That’s the one ipm… thanks for adding that info in!
Cheers!
I’ve only ever got to level 2…
Mr Miser’s cousin and her boyfriend met us for dinner on the South Coast, where they were living with his parents rent free in order to save for a house (ding!). They were telling us about how people found it weird they hadn’t gone and rented a flat in the meantime, but that they felt it was a waste of money (ding!). They also admitted they hadn’t eaten out in months as they were so focused on buying a fixer upper bungalow (ding ding!) that they had no bigger – and I quote “financial priorities” (DING!).
I asked about MMM, but they hadn’t heard of it. Their plan is to do up their home, keep investing in shipping containers(??) and then travel the world.
Everyone else just thinks we’re batshit crazy, but that’s okay, because we feel the same about them.
That’s a cool story!
And haha, shipping containers… that is quite a left field investment if I ever heard of one.
I haven’t reached/got past level 1. Just before I fully embraced FIRE, I mentioned to my boss about MMM. His response was ‘Don’t believe everything you read on the internet…’.
Part of me doesn’t want to play this game properly – people who read MMM may then want to read similar UK blogs and stumble across mine and I don’t want to be discovered by someone I know in RL, haha!
Hi weenie,
You know I had exactly the same worry but then I think the chances of them even reading MMM is quite remote, and then somehow them getting back to here is just very very unlikely. Even then, I haven’t really written anything mean about anyone (to the contrary I would say I’ve been complementary) so hopefully they wouldn’t mind, although they might get annoyed I’ve been writing about them on the internet without their permission I suppose!?
Cheers 🙂
Got to level 2 once when I met a fellow scuba diver (expensive UK hobby!) who admitted he retired early to Thailand so he could live and travel cheaply, and dive every day. He did it by working long hours and weekends in London, saving when his mates were partying and investing in BTL(s). He had never heard of MMM or any of the others. He was a nice unassuming guy following his dream. He lived simply and worked part time sometimes.
Nice photo of the French castle! We’re off to France in September, packing our camping stuff in our Skoda’s huge boot – do you have any travelling tips?
Wow… amazing!
I think there are just as many people who worked out all of this stuff themselves (especially the older generation) than those who stumbled across or searched with intent for the internet FI movement.
Cheers… I am going to do a post next week on how the budget of the trip went so will stick some other general tips in there as well… look out for it 🙂
You have some sample bias here, however, although it’s probably true up to about 45, simply because retiring earlier than that is a really tough ask.
I took great relief in unregistering as SE this month, because the trouble with any sort of regular commitment is that it’s hard to seize opportunities in non-work life. I was nominally on a day a week but it was really about half a day a month by working smarter. But it was still a tie, and one I’m glad to be shot of – I only took that on to help someone out. Hit and run one-off jobs only for me from now on. Work is overrated and part time work is still overrated IMO 😉
Hi ermine,
Totally agree with you there on the sample bias!
I have 9 years till 45 so barring any disasters will be a lot nearer to proper FI by then, so can either go back to work full time and sprint to the finish line or do some mega frugal shit to get my savings rate up to achieve the same.
“Work is overrated and part time work is still overrated IMO” – Agreed 100% with the first part of that and I’m almost certain I will agree with all of it after about another 10 years of it! 🙂
Cheers for chipping in
Great post. Really enjoyed this one.
Just to add to the Child Trust Fund comment, you now get child benefit providing neither of you earn more than £50kpa at which point it tapers off. Worth £82 per month for the first child and slightly less for subsequent. I’m currently investing it on my child’s behalf in an isa (not JISA) until he is around 18.
Also, regarding the part-time work I think a large part of it is linked to identity. It’s difficult to transition from an elite or professional identity to one of retired when everyone else is still on the working path. Plus, sometimes it’s good for some self-actualisation and esteem to go out and do a days work for money. I think the psychological aspect is sometimes overlooked in the FIRE community.
Hi David,
Thanks! Feel free to pay if forward and share my posts if you feel any particular one stands out 🙂 (and thanks if you do!)
That’s a good idea about investing the child benefit. We are just adding it to the income pot and as its all fungible then it just means we have more to potentially invest each month (which I haven’t actually done any for ages as been building up the cash reserves… slightly annoying as I see FTSE is still breaking all time highs as we speak).
So you can open a normal ISA for your kids then? Never knew that.
I agree about the identity thing for part time working, especially if you haven’t got other things in the pipeline to do. I kind of have got some but not sure I have the get up and go to actually go and do them if I quit my part time job so I’m playing it safe for now, especially as I’m enjoying the current arrangement a hell of a lot.
“I think the psychological aspect is sometimes overlooked in the FIRE community.” – Yea most of the more bigger/successful bloggers just assume everyone is like them and can get actualisation themselves without the organisation of a job. “I did this, you should do it too” – it doesn’t work like that in real life of course as everyone is different. Jim at sexhealthmoneydeath.com is a testament to that.
Cheers for the interesting comment, and hope you stop by again soon 🙂
“So you can open a normal ISA for your kids then? ”
I think what he means is that he has got an ISA in his name but that what he saves in there is for his kids, rather than opening a JSA.
There are certain investments in my own ISA which are ‘earmarked’ for my nieces and nephews – I just keep them separate from my own investments in my spreadsheets. I will cash in when they turn 18 and gift it to them.
Cheers weenie, yea that is what I thought he meant too but was just double checking.
Seems to me you will have a new game on your hands from next week onwards … the “did you see that Channel 4 programme about how to retire at forty last week?”!
http://www.channel4.com/programmes/how-to-retire-at-40
Judging by the comments to the online articles (Daily Mail and Independent), expect a lot of negativity!
Yea saw the programme… sounds like it got a bad wrap all round from both the unwashed masses and the FI community. Lose / Lose for the producers there then…!
Great post.
Suggestions for Level 3 & 4
Level 3 – You have to be asked, without prompting, if you have heard of MMM (or similar). I was recently asked by a friend I’ve known for over 30 years and he was just starting to read up on FIRE and knows I don’t work.
Level 4 – Spot a FIRE blogger in the wild. This is obviously a lot harder to complete.
Amazing!
I think I would wet my pants if someone asked ME about that totally unprovoked. Haha!
Level 4 sounds very hard unless it was an organised event, which obviously wouldn’t count… 🙂
My husband and I both retired around the same time, 6 years ago. I was 56, he was 63. We headed off on our travels for a couple of months, then my husband got a call from his previous employer. Would he be prepared to continue work part-time, in his own time, doing only the work he wanted to (heavy duty engineering maths!)? This has proved to be an excellent answer. He enjoys the work, wanders into the office every month or two, gets the odd trip which he enjoys, but still has all the flexibility he needs to travel the world as we had planned (laptop and wi-fi are all he needs!)
We put all his salary away in a pension pot, which hopefully we will never need, and can be left to the kids…
For me, part-time wouldn’t have worked. I would have been doing full-time before I could have blinked… So I don’t work at all and indeed have no desire to.
It’s all about Choice!
Hi Erith,
Sounds perfect!
Glad you managed to find freedom and your husband worked something out with his work that he is enjoying.
Enjoy your travels 🙂
Ooh, do I get a point for spotting someone on the tram to work reading ‘Rich Dad, Poor Dad’?
Oh yea defo some bonus points on offer there weenie!!
Good spotting 🙂